America in Denial as Fiscal Tsunami Approaches

It’s hard to hear yourself think over all the caterwauling on
Capitol Hill about the looming sequestration “crisis.” For
opponents of the spending cuts—at $85 billion, 2.3 percent of the
$3.6 trillion federal budget—the rallying cry is half Lord Keynes,
half St. Augustine: “Grant me chastity and continence—but not
But the time for a little fiscal continence has long since
arrived. Economists have found that when a country’s debt-to-GDP
ratio surpasses 90 percent, you see slower economic growth; we’re
currently above 100 percent.
True, the sequester is somewhat ham-fisted in its execution;
departments cannot prioritize the across-the-board percentage cuts.
Still, too much discretion results in too little restraint, as
we’ve learned from the 2011 budget deal, which cut $38 billion on
Two weeks ago, the Washington Post looked at that deal,
which President Obama called “the largest annual spending cut in
our history.” “Stuffed with gimmicks” and “phantom cuts,” the deal
was “an epic kind of Washington illusion,” the Post reported. At
least $17 billion of the ballyhooed $38 billion in reductions “cut
nothing at all”; the feds absorbed the reductions “without losing a
single employee.”
The sequester may be a rough tool, but it doesn’t allow for as
much cooking the books.
Stories like this that encourage us to believe that our fiscal
dilemma stems in the main from “weak-willed politicians.” But as
New York Times economics columnist and Washington Bureau
Chief David Leonhardt writes in his crisp and informative new
e-book “Here’s the Deal,” that lets the rest of us off too easily:
“The problem is us—the voters.”
I don’t agree with many of the solutions he proposes but I can’t
fault his diagnosis: “[T]he coming deficits stem, above all, from
the fact that most Americans are scheduled to receive far more in
Medicare benefits than they have paid in Medicare taxes. Social
Security contributes to the problem, too, as do the world’s largest
military” and an electorate that has decided “Republicans have won
the debate on taxes, and Democrats have won the debate on
A new survey from the Pew Research Center underscores
Leonhardt’s point: “As Sequester Deadline Looms, Little Support for
Cutting Most Programs.” “For 18 of 19 programs tested,” the survey
finds, “majorities want either to increase spending or maintain it
at current levels.”
Of the 19 programs tested, not one earns a plurality of
Democrats favoring decreased spending. Republicans talk tough in
the abstract, but they’re nearly as incontinent when it comes to
specifics: Only cuts to foreign aid and unemployment assistance
show majority support from GOP voters.
But, as Leonhardt makes clear, our looming fiscal calamity is
hardly the result of freebies for poor people and foreigners. Much
of it is the result of middle-class entitlements, particularly in
health care. He cites research showing that in current dollars, a
newly retired married couple with typical earnings will have paid
roughly $88,000 in payroll taxes for Medicare (including the
employer contribution); they can expect to receive program benefits
more than four times that much.
The U.S. “already has a ‘particularly strong age bias’ in its
government spending” relative to other rich nations, he writes, and
the burden of fiscal restructuring is likely to fall hardest on the
young. This complicates the “makers vs. takers” narrative that Mitt
Romney, Rep. Paul Ryan and their supporters have indulged in to
explain their loss. This class of net “takers”—older voters—tends
to vote Republican.
In recent budget fights, the federal legislators most closely
aligned with the Ron Paul wing of the Tea Party movement—Sen. Rand
Paul (R-Ky.) and Rep. Justin Amash (R-Mich.)—have been most willing
to embrace the sequester and call for further cuts. But they’re a
distinct minority: The fiscal reality-based community remains far
too small.
This article
originally appeared at The Washington Examiner.

See the original article here: 

America in Denial as Fiscal Tsunami Approaches

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,

Leave a Reply


Recent Posts


%d bloggers like this: